Total backup cost starts with the same delivered service: which loads remain powered and for how long. Comparing the price of a generator with a battery container is misleading when one quote includes switching equipment and the other excludes the PCS or transformer.

Count the ownership period

TCO includes purchasing, delivery, operation, scheduled replacements and end-of-use costs. Generator costs depend heavily on actual running hours and fuel consumption at the operating load. Battery costs depend on usable energy, losses, calendar ageing and cycling. Infrequent emergency backup and daily tariff dispatch have different cost structures even with identical nameplate capacity.

Use the right denominator

Divide energy cost by energy actually delivered to the load. Do not substitute nameplate capacity for annual throughput. A rarely discharged emergency battery may be valuable because it preserves a process, rather than because each delivered kilowatt-hour is cheap. Value avoided downtime from the business's own records, not an industry-wide number.

Compare three scenarios

Model an ordinary year, frequent outages and a prolonged blackout. In each, check fuel or charging-energy availability, maintenance and remaining battery capacity. One average energy price hides these differences. An equipment comparison from USK Energy should show both the supply scope and the assumptions behind its result.

Define the service before comparing its cost

Backup can be valued per hour of readiness, per kilowatt-hour actually delivered or per production task completed. These are different measures. An emergency generator that hardly runs during a year will have a high cost per generated kilowatt-hour. That does not automatically make it a poor purchase: the business paid for readiness for an infrequent but consequential event. A battery kept full for backup should likewise not be assessed as though it performs daily tariff arbitrage.

Set the same comparison boundary: an agreed load group, required duration and allowable interruption. A proposal supplying the whole facility is not an alternative to one protecting only the server room, even if both quote a similar battery capacity. Align the function first, the scope second and the costs last.

Keep two linked calculations: the owner's cash payments by year and the technical balance of energy and operating hours. Combining them immediately into one “price per kWh” makes it easier to lose a battery replacement, charging losses or generator maintenance. The separate schedules also make it possible to update a tariff without rewriting technical assumptions.

Cost lines that belong in the comparison

Split initial expenditure into equipment, delivery, necessary auxiliary components and separately contracted work. For BESS, the scope may include battery cabinets, PCS, controls, metering, switching and equipment for the required voltage. For a generator it may include the generating set, automation and agreed fuel and auxiliary systems. A component missing from a quotation has not necessarily become unnecessary at the site.

Build operating expenditure from identifiable lines. For storage, include charging electricity, auxiliaries, scheduled maintenance, software charges and future replacements. For the generator, include fuel, consumables, service labour, test runs and repair assumptions. Apply taxes and recoverable VAT consistently to both alternatives using the company's accounting model.

Do not automatically include every imaginable replacement. State the trigger: a resource limit, inability to meet the required autonomy, or the end of supported operation. A component warranty may exclude removal, freight and recommissioning. If those activities remain the customer's responsibility, they need their own cost lines.

Variable cost is not the full ownership cost

Suppose one event requires 120 kWh delivered to the load. With an illustrative charging price of UAH 5/kWh and round-trip efficiency of 90% at the agreed boundary, restoring that delivered energy requires about 133.3 kWh, costing approximately UAH 666.7. If auxiliaries are already included in the efficiency figure, do not add them twice. Otherwise account for them separately using the relevant operating mode.

For an illustrative generator scenario, assume 0.32 litres per delivered kWh and fuel priced at UAH 60/litre. Fuel alone costs 120 × 0.32 × 60 = UAH 2,304. These are arithmetic assumptions, not a specification for a particular generator or a statement of current fuel prices. A real calculation uses the selected unit's consumption at the actual loading level, preferably supported by records from existing equipment.

The difference between those amounts is not net BESS profit. It excludes acquisition, calendar ageing, repairs, unavailable periods and the cost of capital. Infrequent outages may produce too few annual events to justify additional investment even when variable costs differ substantially. Increasing the number of cycles must also remain compatible with the battery's operating limits and warranty.

One convenient year is not enough

Model at least three operating cases: rare emergency use, the expected year and an extended adverse period. Change concrete inputs, including backup hours, charging opportunities, energy prices, fuel consumption and replenishment availability. Do not simply multiply a favourable savings total by an arbitrary percentage. Record which assumptions stay fixed across the cases.

Check whether the intervals between events allow the proposed schedule. A battery may support the first outage but lack time to recharge for the second. A generator may have sufficient rated power yet require service within the extended scenario. A calculation that omits those interruptions compares ideal sources rather than purchasable packages.

Keep operating costs separate from the consequences of production downtime. Lost sales value is not automatically the loss incurred for each stopped hour. The relevant estimate may include contribution margin, rejected product, restart costs and disruption of later processes. Agree the method with finance and production staff rather than making any expensive package appear profitable through an inflated downtime value.

Residual value and unequal operating lives

When the comparison horizon is shorter than the equipment's useful operation, an asset may retain value at the end. Do not equate this with its purchase price or an invented guaranteed resale price. Show residual value as a distinct assumption and also test a zero-residual-value case.

If a component is replaced within the horizon, compare the same final service. A new battery may retain useful life beyond the chosen end date. Long-term cash payments should be discounted using the company's agreed method. Nominal cash flows containing inflation and a real discount rate cannot be mixed casually. Financing treatment should also be consistent between the alternatives.

A table that explains the difference

Comparison lineInput evidenceBuyer's check
Equipment purchaseSpecification and quotationMatching scope and exclusions
Charging electricitySupply contract and energy balanceLosses counted once
Generator fuelUnit curve or operating recordsActual loading pattern
MaintenanceSchedule and service quotationLabour, materials and availability
ReplacementsWarranty and operating scenarioTrigger and expected payment year
Unavailable periodsAgreed operating scenarioService continuity during maintenance

Send this table to USK Energy even if some cells are initially blank. The supplier can describe equipment and documented performance, while the business supplies its tariff and operating profile. Clear input ownership makes quotations comparable and exposes the assumptions that actually determine the purchase decision. Keep the original workbook and its version date so later price revisions do not erase the reasoning behind the selected package.

For an existing generator, distinguish historic expenditure from future payments. The original purchase is not a new investment in the option of continuing to use it. When adding BESS, compare future costs with and without storage. If the generator remains for extended outages, calendar maintenance does not automatically disappear when operating hours fall. Ask service providers to separate time-based and running-hour costs before claiming the difference as a battery benefit.

Your inputs

Your storage-cost scenario

Change the inputs and save the result to discuss the equipment package.

Cost per discounted delivered energy—UAH/kWh
Total undiscounted energy delivered—kWh
Present value of modelled expenditure—UAH

LCOS = present expenditure / discounted delivered energy. Annual delivery declines by the entered fraction; charging energy = delivery / efficiency. Costs and energy are discounted at year-end. The separate payment does not reset ageing. Excludes revenue, residual value, tax and inflation; initial values are illustrative. Use one currency and price basis across all years.

Before requesting a quotation

Mark questions for which you already have a confirmed answer. Save the list and send unresolved points to the supplier.

Before requesting a quotation
0 / 3
Why the tariff spread is not the whole calculation

Compare costs for the same delivered service: energy reaching the load and the share of demand actually supported. Charging prices apply to input energy; savings apply to output energy. Conversion losses, auxiliary consumption and reserve constraints sit between the two. Demand-charge savings are a separate benefit only when your actual supply contract includes that charge.

Change charging cost, displaced energy cost and cycle efficiency in the example below. A negative result is useful: the tariff scenario does not even cover energy losses. A positive result is not a payback forecast. Maintenance, degradation, financing and other costs still need to be deducted before comparing the remaining benefit with the investment.

Further verification

USK Energy / B2B

From calculation to equipment

Preparing an equipment purchase? Send the load, backup duration or specification. USK Energy will clarify the configuration, compatibility and delivery terms.