A cheap-to-expensive price difference creates an opportunity for storage only if it reaches your supply contract. A wholesale price chart alone does not establish the charging cost, final saving or right to export electricity.
Check the bill formula
Identify hourly prices, the supplier's margin and other payment components. Not every charge disappears when storage shifts consumption. For exports, use the sale price under the relevant contract rather than the retail purchase price. Keep taxes and other charges on a consistent basis throughout the comparison.
Losses can consume the spread
Illustrative example: delivering 100 kWh with 80% round-trip efficiency requires 125 kWh of charging energy. At a charging price of UAH 4 and displaced purchase price of UAH 8, the energy-cost difference is 800 − 500 = UAH 300. This excludes capital costs, wear and maintenance. Change the inputs below and find the point where the result becomes negative.
Do not assume every day is identical
Test consecutive real days: the battery may not finish charging, the spread may narrow or the emergency reserve may be needed during an expensive hour. Send USK Energy your consumption history and price formula. These inputs allow equipment power and capacity to be compared without inventing a guaranteed daily income.
The price on a market chart is not necessarily your marginal cost
For a BESS calculation, use the part of the electricity bill that actually changes when consumption moves between intervals. A fixed monthly charge does not disappear because charging takes place in a cheaper hour. Network, contractual and other components may also be treated differently. Begin with the supply agreement and an actual invoice rather than the most dramatic daily market chart.
Store the timestamp, consumption, applicable price and units for every interval. Prices expressed in UAH/MWh must be converted when the energy model uses kWh. A thousandfold unit error is surprisingly easy to miss when every result is immediately presented as a large annual total. Manually reconcile one day with the relevant billing calculation before processing a full year.
Reducing on-site purchases is different from exporting electricity. A battery discharging only into an internal load group is limited by that group's simultaneous consumption. Export requires its own technical and contractual arrangements. A bidirectional inverter does not, by itself, establish that the business can sell energy to the grid.
The minimum spread after losses
Let the charging price be Ccharge and the avoided purchase price be Cdischarge. With round-trip efficiency η, delivering one kilowatt-hour requires purchasing 1 / η kilowatt-hours at the agreed input boundary. The energy margin is Cdischarge − Ccharge / η. Deduct any additional variable cost per delivered kilowatt-hour separately. The equation requires consistent efficiency boundaries.
At an illustrative charging price of UAH 4.5/kWh and 90% round-trip efficiency, the energy cost of a delivered kilowatt-hour is already UAH 5. Discharging instead of buying at UAH 5.2 creates only UAH 0.2 of energy margin before other costs. The visible UAH 0.7 price spread is not battery margin. If the displaced price is UAH 4.8, the operation increases energy expenditure even before ageing is considered.
Do not arbitrarily allocate the entire equipment purchase cost to the threshold for every individual dispatch decision. Operational decisions require an agreed estimate of incremental cost and wear. The investment decision requires the full cash flow. These related questions are nevertheless different: whether to perform a particular cycle, and whether to buy the equipment at all.
Why the cheapest hour may be too short
Suppose the system must deliver 200 kWh. At 90% round-trip efficiency, replenishing that delivered energy requires approximately 222.2 kWh at the agreed input boundary. A two-hour charging opportunity therefore requires an average input power above 111 kW in this simplified example. A package limited to 50 kW of charging cannot follow that schedule merely because its nominal energy capacity is sufficient.
Now check the site connection. Add the facility's existing consumption and any auxiliaries not already included. During cheap hours, an energy-intensive shift may already be running. Available connection headroom can therefore be lower than the PCS rating. EMS must respect actual headroom instead of commanding full charging power simply because a time schedule says to charge.
The same check applies to discharge. A high price may last briefly while internal demand is small. Without permitted export, the battery cannot deliver the planned volume just because the algorithm finds the price attractive. Select power and energy capacity from actual windows rather than a universal “two-hour battery” rule.
Emergency reserve has an opportunity cost
If the site requires a permanent backup reserve, deduct that energy from the amount available for tariff dispatch. A calculation cannot use a complete commercial discharge and separately promise full backup duration at every moment. An outage can begin immediately after the commercial discharge has finished.
An EMS enquiry should define priorities: the minimum SOC, who may change it, the response to an outage warning and behaviour after communications are lost. Calculate two schedules, with and without the protected reserve. Their difference shows the potential tariff benefit sacrificed to maintain greater emergency readiness.
This does not mean reserve should be minimised for profit. At many facilities, backup is the primary purchasing reason and tariff operation is secondary. The useful question is which operating modes preserve the agreed emergency service and whether their benefit justifies any additional controls, metering and software cost.
Backtesting without knowledge of the future
A calculation that selects the cheapest and most expensive hours after a day has ended assumes perfect price knowledge. It can provide an upper benchmark under the stated technical constraints, but it does not establish achievable controller performance. Compare it with a schedule formed from information actually available when each decision had to be made.
Request a chronological historical replay with continuous SOC tracking. Each day must inherit the previous day's ending charge, rather than beginning with a convenient full battery. Include weekends, production changes, missing data and unavailable equipment. Validate the result on a period that was not used to tune the strategy.
Keep rejected dispatch opportunities in the output. Reasons such as insufficient charging time, protected reserve, no internal demand or an import limit are useful procurement information. They reveal whether buying more energy capacity, more power or neither would improve the result. A single annual savings figure conceals that distinction.
Information for a BESS and EMS quotation
| Input | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Contract price formula and invoice | Establish the actual variable cost |
| Interval consumption profile | Test charging and useful discharge in time |
| Import and export limits | Exclude unavailable operating modes |
| Protected SOC reserve | Align economics with backup duration |
| Charge and discharge ratings | Establish achievable throughput |
| Command and measurement logs | Verify operation after delivery |
Ask for the energy result, additional costs and model restrictions to be shown separately. Tell USK Energy whether local control without a cloud service is required, which meters already exist and who will maintain tariff data. This helps identify equipment functions the business will actually use. Preserve the original data and agreed assumptions so a tariff change can be assessed without rebuilding the entire procurement comparison.
Keep tariff rules as separate model inputs. A new supply agreement may change the value of the same dispatch schedule without any equipment fault. Compare the optimised strategy with a simple feasible schedule using identical reserve and connection limits. If the advanced controller adds little measurable benefit, review its data, settings and subscription cost before purchasing further software functions.
Price difference after losses
Change the inputs and save the result to discuss the equipment package.
E is delivered AC energy; efficiency covers the full cycle at the same boundary. Δ = E × displaced price − E / efficiency × charging price. Initial prices are illustrative. Excludes CAPEX, lifetime consumption, service, taxes and charges not included in your input prices. A positive result does not establish payback.
Before requesting a quotation
Mark questions for which you already have a confirmed answer. Save the list and send unresolved points to the supplier.
Why the tariff spread is not the whole calculation
Compare costs for the same delivered service: energy reaching the load and the share of demand actually supported. Charging prices apply to input energy; savings apply to output energy. Conversion losses, auxiliary consumption and reserve constraints sit between the two. Demand-charge savings are a separate benefit only when your actual supply contract includes that charge.
Change charging cost, displaced energy cost and cycle efficiency in the example below. A negative result is useful: the tariff scenario does not even cover energy losses. A positive result is not a payback forecast. Maintenance, degradation, financing and other costs still need to be deducted before comparing the remaining benefit with the investment.
Further verification
From calculation to equipment
Preparing an equipment purchase? Send the load, backup duration or specification. USK Energy will clarify the configuration, compatibility and delivery terms.




